Critique Blaven and Loch Cill Chriosd

SFTPhotography

Ranger Smith
Suspended / Banned
Messages
20,926
Name
Steve
Edit My Images
Yes
Took a wee road trip up to Skye a couple of weeks ago. I finally had the pleasure meeting @Steelo who was taking someone on a 121 workshop. They got a belting day for it for sure.

I just love reflections, ok. It is what I will shoot whenever the chance arises. Nothing quite does it for me the way still water does and with a low wind speed forecasted it seemed rude not to take a wee run through the night up to Broadford then swing a left for Elgol.

I've been here before but it was a grab and go when I saw the reflections in my passanger side mirror as I was coming back from Elgol. This time I thought I would do it properly and take a similar version to the image I took last October.

Sunrise was wonderful as the light transitioned. Truth be told this isn't really the best spot on the Loch and I realised further back was where I needed to be. Still, I I loosed off two from here

_DSC0613 by Stephen Taylor, on Flickr

_DSC0620 by Stephen Taylor, on Flickr

This was probably the keeper from the set and cropped 7x5 to remove an ugly road sign from the far left corner and also a little unwanted corner softness on the 70-200 f4. I tend to find Nikkor lenses at the short and long end of their zoom range quite poor (on my copies anyway), its in the middle parts they perform well.

_DSC0025_Version 2 by Stephen Taylor, on Flickr

Composition wise this is an interesting spot mind you. Further back from the south end of the Loch and there is a break from the reeds. Getting lower helps frame more of the reflection but it starts to place the reeds higher and higher in the frame. Personally I prefer the lower perspective even though the reeds start to cut into the mountain. I took two from here as the light changed. From an optical point of view you are in the mid part of the 24-70 range where everything is sharp. From 60-70mm and 24-28mm the lens is unusable with blurry corners and sharp centers.

_DSC0638 by Stephen Taylor, on Flickr

and

_DSC0641 by Stephen Taylor, on Flickr

I am off to Skye tonight for sunrise. The winds might be a bit too high for the reflections but I hope not. If not its Elgol or the Quairing for my sunrise but the plan is to take the last composition of this frame with the lighting of the 1st two. That is the winner for me.
 
Last edited:
Lovely takes Steve - the last 3 have the most impact on me, probably number 3 being my fave as it has a nice balance of light and shadow. The first two while nice feel a touch cramped at the bottom with the reeds touching the edge of the frame, the extra room they've got at the bottom in the others works a bit better for me.
 
Lovely takes Steve - the last 3 have the most impact on me, probably number 3 being my fave as it has a nice balance of light and shadow. The first two while nice feel a touch cramped at the bottom with the reeds touching the edge of the frame, the extra room they've got at the bottom in the others works a bit better for me.

Yep I'd agree with that. I need to go back and get the light of the 1st three with the composition of the last two.

You'll notice also with the first two you see more of Blaven but the way to Loch and Reeds lye you get the issue you highlight.

Further round and back you see less of the mountain but you can put clean air between the reeds, reflection etc like the last two images.

It's one of the harder ones to do as every composition is a compromise in some shape or form.

Going to check it out tomorrow but suspect it'll be a tad too windy to pull it off so looking at the Quairing
 
2nd has lovely light, 3rd is my favourite. Out of 4 and 5 I prefer the brighter contrast of 5. Those yellows are always a bit hard to process though!
 
Back
Top