Direction : Clearly on theme, it looks well lit... I just feel it's lacking in something to really make it. Perhaps one of the pieces on the corner of the square ?? Which one looks most dejected ??
Fear : I think the second works best... th elighting is better controlled and the focus is more appropriate for the image. A very dark take on the theme, but I think it works, although I think it probably needs the text to explain
Sigh : Not totally convinced for the theme, but it's a tough theme. A very nicely captured image, good strong detail, and bang on focus. I think it works better in mono.